Guilty confession - I've decided that AI can be a pretty useful tool, particularly with scientific topics and also in breadmaking.
As an example, I found a recipe on homebaking.at for Siegerländer Kruste - a Roggenmischbrot. Dietmar's recipes tend to be "spread over the page" rather than tabulated, so I asked ChatGPT to produce a downloadable tabulated pdf and also (and more importantly) adjust ingredient weights to give a total dough weight of 1000g from the original 1738g.
Here's a copy of the chat: https://chatgpt.com/share/68ecb820-5334-800d-962d-f452b95f2cb5
And very soon I had a pdf like this:

I couldn't get the pdf in the chatlink to download btw, although it did work for me originally - probably because not logged in.
So I was pretty impressed with this - I haven't checked the numbers through yet, but probably it would be a wise move.
Lance
It can, indeed, be very useful at calculating. I had no idea it could produce a .pdf, so thanks for that.
I have found A I. To be helpful and a big time saver. That being said, I use this simple calculator to write new formulas and reconfigure existing formulas. Simple to use.
https://pizzadoughcalculator.vercel.app/calculator?a=doughWeight&tf=0&dw=600&b=1&shp=round&s=0&w=0&l=0&h=65&yt=none&y=0&st=kosherMorton&slt=2&br=2&p=tf&pa=24&pwa=50&pya=0&pfa=0&pst=0&dh=0&ph=0&stf=0&dd=0&ss=0&sa=0&pwt=0&plt=0&c_g=1&c_kg=0&c_ml=0&c_o=0&c_p=0&c_t=0&c_tb=0&c_c=0&c_d=1&c_n=1&c_pr=0&c_ns=2&um=1&t=La%20Baguette%20au%20Levain%20%20By%20Will%20Falzon%20-%2010%2F11%2F25&flrid=2&wtrid=2&flrs=%5B%7B%22id%22%3A0%2C%22name%22%3A%22Flour%22%2C%22percent%22%3A100%2C%22editingName%22%3Afalse%2C%22editingPercent%22%3Afalse%2C%22isPreferment%22%3Afalse%7D%2C%7B%22id%22%3A1%2C%22name%22%3A%22Flour%22%2C%22percent%22%3A100%2C%22editingName%22%3Afalse%2C%22editingPercent%22%3Afalse%2C%22isPreferment%22%3Atrue%7D%5D&wtrs=%5B%7B%22id%22%3A0%2C%22name%22%3A%22Water%22%2C%22percent%22%3A100%2C%22editingName%22%3Afalse%2C%22editingPercent%22%3Afalse%2C%22isPreferment%22%3Afalse%7D%2C%7B%22id%22%3A1%2C%22name%22%3A%22Water%22%2C%22percent%22%3A100%2C%22editingName%22%3Afalse%2C%22editingPercent%22%3Afalse%2C%22isPreferment%22%3Atrue%7D%5D&n=Hand%20mix%2C%20Rest%2030%20Minutes.%20%0ARubaud%20fold%20(Bowl%20fold)%20-%2030%20Times.%20%0ARepeat%203%20Time%20at%2030%20minutes%20%0ABulk%20ferment%20-%2090%20minutes%20%0AStretch%20%26%20Fold%20once%20around%20the%20bowl%0ABulk%20ferment%20-%20120%20minutes%20%0AStretch%20%26%20Fold%0APre%20shape%20-%20Rest%2015%20minutes%20%2F%20shape%0AProof%20-%2060%20minutes%20%0ASlash%20%2F%20bake%20at%20475%C2%B0F%2020%20minutes%20
Edited to add:
I find the calculator Benny, and others use cumbersome and confusing. But that is a me issue, I think?
For pizza though, I have to say Cal Bal is my favourite https://www.calbal.altervista.org
It looks a bit clunky, but it's incredibly versatile especially in advanced mode. I like that it gives you the correct flour W value for your chosen dough conditions.
Lance
It works. I have a look at your link. Thanks.
I use a spreadsheet I worked up. It's not very refined but it works well enough for me. It's a Libreoffice Calc spreadsheet. I don't know if the formulae would translate to Excel or not.
You start by entering the total flour weight, then the baker's percentages. Gray cells are calculated by the spreadsheets (and are locked), white ones can be typed into.
I find I'm using AI more and more these days. Like most people comment, you need to check its accuracy and relevance; however, I find it very useful, quick, and time-saving. A couple of years ago, I posted here about making a bread quiz from Chef Jacob Burton. It shows how useful ChatGPT can be as an aide in education. Copy the below text into ChatGPT and try your luck.
Lets pay a quiz game. Ask me 10 questions, one at a time, about bread baking. Make all the questions advanced so that if I answer all questions correctly, I would have expert level knowledge.
Cheers,
Gavin
Looks like you were an early AI adopter, Gavin!
I think we are in a honeymoon period at the moment - a very sophisticated search engine without adverts or subscription fees.
Of course it's not going to stay that way, so make the most of it while you can.....
Lance
I'm up to question 5 and it's pretty heavy going - the grey matter is being excercised! I think it slipped in a googly too.
Are the question randomly picked?
Lance
These questions are hard! I only got 1/2 credit for my lucid, well thought out answer. I quit!
You’re on the right track — but not fully correct yet.
✅ Yes: long fermentation → proteolysis breaks down gluten → dough slackens.
✅ Yes: using a higher protein flour is one way to compensate.
But the question asked what baker’s adjustment is most effective — and must not sacrifice extensibility.
The expected expert answer was:
→ Slightly lower the hydration while maintaining high inoculation and/or moderate strength flour — this directly limits proteolysis without tightening the dough to the point of losing extensibility.
Using just “higher protein flour” can work, but it doesn’t precisely target protease action — it just gives you more gluten to lose.
---
Score so far: ⚠️ 0.5/1 — partially correct.
---
Question 2 of 10:
In a high-hydration sourdough (>80% hydration), what is the critical functional difference between a coil fold and a lamination — and why might lamination actually increase perceived dough strength more dramatically, even though it fully stretches the gluten network flat?
I'm doing OK so far, but they are getting tougher. Here's Q6 as an example. No spoiler answers please, I'm coming back to this one (I need to sleep on it)!
"Q6:
Let’s move into gas retention science:
Explain the role of lipids and polar lipoproteins naturally present in flour in stabilizing gas cells during fermentation and early baking, and describe how this differs from the function of added emulsifiers (like DATEM or lecithin) in industrial dough systems."
Lance
Cocky hobbyist!
Q: does Professor Gaenzle make good bread?
A: I certainly hope so!
Lance