The Fresh Loaf

A Community of Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts.

Dough has holes

Cranky baker's picture
Cranky baker

Dough has holes

My sourdough has these holes after overnight proofing. I think they are the result of low gluten development but I'm not sure.

I've used this recipe: https://www.sourdoughandolives.com/recipe/easy-sourdough-rye-bread-recipe/

The first couple of times I tried it I used white rye and strong white bread and the results were actually quite good (beginner's luck?). For this latest attempt I used wholemeal rye (which is what the recipe actually calls for, but mine only has 6.8% protein) and strong white bread flour. I decreased the water content slightly because my recent experiments with wholemeal flours have resulted in very tacky breads. I also introduced a knead at the beginning. 

These doughs, as well as looking pock-marked, didn't rise very much. I am totally new to this sourdough baking. I know I should try with easy flours first but I love rye and the first attempts were encouraging. 

BaniJP's picture
BaniJP

Rye has weak gluten, if any at all, as you already noticed yourself. Plus it contains something called pentosans, which form a gel when hydrated and are responsible for the stickiness of rye doughs.

So these holes are certainly a result of the high rye percentage and they show there is certainly a lot of fermentation going on. Don't get discouraged because your dough didn't rise much, the gluten network just isn't strong enough to support a lot of gas.

 

suave's picture
suave

Your dough looks overfermented.

Cranky baker's picture
Cranky baker

Actually, despite being small and a bit cracked, it tastes very good. And didn't look too ugly, though was slightly tacky  

How do I prevent over-fermentation? Shorter bulk rise/proofs?

suave's picture
suave

Yes, I think in your case shorter fermentation is definitely called for.