The Fresh Loaf

News & Information for Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts

Grilled pizza on a Weber

Catomi's picture

Grilled pizza on a Weber

When it starts getting hot and muggy out, my husband and I start grilling more. Today was hot and muggy for sure. Grilled pizzas sounded like just the thing. I've fixed the Cook's Illustrated version several times before, usually with white whole wheat flour (that being what I had). Today I had the bread flour the recipe called for, so I went ahead and used it. I'm blaming the difficulties I had on that change in flours. 

Here is the dough after I mixed it up, plus what was stuck to my oiled hand. 


The dough seemed pretty wet and sticky to me, but it's always a bit of a pain, and besides, I've been getting a tiny bit of experience with high hydration doughs. How bad could it be? Unfortunately I forgot to take into account that I can handle my loaf doughs with parchment paper, but the pizza dough would need to be picked up and put directly on the grate. It's a good thing my son wasn't outside riding his bike while I cooked, he might have picked up some choice words. 

I mixed the dough together, "kneaded" with a spoon for about a minute, and attempted some folds. Then I poured it into an enthusiastically oiled bowl (forgot I was oiling a bowl and not starting a stir fry) and allowed to rise at room temp of 80 degrees for about 2 hours. Then the dough was divided into four parts and shaped into approximately 10-12" ameboids. 

During the last 20 min of rise I started a full chimney of coals. Once they were going well I poured them evenly over half the grill, leaving half bare. I heated and cleaned the grate and was ready to go. Each piece of dough was carefully detached from the parchment paper and transferred to the grill surface directly over the coals. During this process, the dough generally acquired a significantly different shape. It was grilled until the bottom was done, by which I mean anywhere from "cooked through enough to handle" to "extra crispy." Then each piece was transferred, cooked side up, back off the heat to have toppings added. 

The pizzas were brushed with olive oil flavored with crushed garlic and Aleppo pepper. Then they were topped with tomatoes (chopped, tossed with salt and drained in a strainer for 30 min or so to keep them from making the crust soggy), a mix of fontina and pecorino romano cheeses, and fresh basil (added after cooking). They went back on the cooler side of the grill, with the lid on, to melt the cheese and finish cooking the crust. The addition of toppings did hide some of the minor irregularities, but there was no hiding some holes. Pizzas were served with tabbouleh and a grilled ratatouille salad, and consumed with gusto by my family. 

This being my first grilled pizza venture of the summer, I found it a bit stressful. I had to remind myself of the number 2 rule of making grilled pizzas, "go easy on yourself."  The number one rule is, of course, "have a place for everything to go, and everything in its place." Things move quickly once the dough hits the grate. 

Here are some finished pizzas. These weren't the best, and weren't the worst. 


How I made them: (amounts are from CI, but I tweaked the technique slightly)

Mix: 260 g warm tap water

22 g olive oil

4 g active dry yeast

10 g sugar

Allow yeast to foam (I did this because mine was old and I wanted to make sure it was active). Meanwhile, mix:

312 g KA bread flour

15 g white whole wheat flour

12 g table salt

Add the yeast mixture when ready and stir thoroughly to combine. "Knead" (stir) for about 1 minute. Transfer to an oiled bowl, cover and let rise until doubled (mine may have overrisen). Divide into four balls, flatten slightly and let rest 10 min. Shape (using lots of extra flour) and transfer to the grill to cook as above. 

Crust: soft and chewy in parts. Crunchy and cracker-like in others. A few holes charred straight through. 


Up next, I may have to try baking bread in the dutch oven on the grill. My husband successfully roasted a chicken in there over the weekend, and I get tired very quickly of heating the house when it's already warm out. Has anyone tried this?


isand66's picture

 I have a great recipe for grilled pizza dough from Peter Reinhart's Pizza book.  I can PM it to you if you are interested.

One of the main parts of the recipe is to let the dough balls sit in plastic bags with a couple of TBS of olive oil and then when you are ready to make the pizza you turn the bags inside out onto an oiled sheet pan.  You then par-bake the dough directly on the grill like you did.  I even used to grill extra dough and let it cool and bake a few days later.  This is also great for parties so you don't have to run around so much.  The other option you have is to use a pizza stone directly on the grill and use parchment paper.  This is what I currently do with my special pizza set-up for my kettle grill.  I am able to get the temperature up over 800 degrees.

For the best pizza you will ever have order some Capputo 00 pizza flour and use that mixed with a little whole wheat.

I have never used a dutch oven on the grill.  I have thought about it and there is no reason why it shouldn't work, but you are going to have to monitor the temperature and make sure you don't burn the bottom of your bread.


Catomi's picture

For some reason it would never have occurred to me to parcook the pizzas. That would decrease stress for sure, and might actually make it feasible for me to fix grilled pizzas at a family get together, which my husband would love. Thanks! He's asked me to do so before and I've refused, saying that cooking four pizzas was quite enough. I almost used parchment paper directly on the grill yesterday before realizing that (duh) it's paper and the grill contains fire. That would have been exciting. 

I wonder if using the stone with the dutch oven on the grill would help protect the bottom of the crust from burning. That was my major concern, not helped by the fact that my oven crusts have had some pretty dark bottoms. I just ordered a combo cooker, though, and read a suggestion on Girl Meets Rye to invert the top when removing it to alow browning, invert it and place the bottom containing the bread atop the lid for the rest of baking. She said that should help protect the bottom from burning. 

If you have the time to type up the recipe, I'd love to have a copy. I have Reinhart's whole wheat bread book, and it has a pizza recipe but it says nothing about grilling it (I haven't tried it either way). His recipes are rather wordy, though. Thanks again. 

porichines1987's picture