September 21, 2011 - 7:49am
Serving up Wood
I thought TFL'ers might be interested in reading this post by Miriam Reimer concerning the wood pulp that is served up every day by the food producer factories in America and the World. The list of 15 food companies that serve you "Wood" surprised me. I especially liked the quote about how pleased one industry spokesman was at being able to add 15% cellulose to a loaf of bread. Wood pulp is not digestible and has no nutritional value to humans. The list of products containing this stretcher is shocking.
Eric
That is really disgusting :(
when I lived in Canada and once I found a wood chip in my bread. I asked the cook why and he told me it added fiber in our diet.
siuflower
Interesting piece. Explains the high count of wooden but regular people around...,
Wild-Yeast
I'm not sure it is disgusting. We take fiber supplements to help clean the digestive system and salads for the same purpose. Cellulose is just more of the same. It seems a little creepy to know that it is added to syrup and ice cream.
Eric
Whole wheat flowers, vegetables, fruits have enough fibers + all the vitamins, minerals and micro-elements that comes with them (and human body can process).Does wood provide you with all that. I don't think so. ;)
Beavers will never forgive us :D
I'm a little uncomfortable with the "obvious assumption" that no-nutritive-value ==> bad-for-you. As far as I know my Metamucil doesn't have any nutritive value either. (And a "fiber" ingredient is important to many gluten-free flour replacements.) I'd prefer to eat real foods that integrated fiber, but getting fiber by itself instead doesn't seem like the worst thing to me...
I'm in agreement Chuck. Although I'm uncomfortable with the idea that the FDA has no limit on how much you can consume in a product. Really? The food scientists are too clever to have that kind of freedom.
Eric
It's just unnecessary tampering with the food with one reason: Profit
BTW pulping can involve heavy chemistry (not very healthy at all) and i'm sure that the big international food companies are buying as cheap pulp as possible (remember the profit ). ;)
It's known that less processed food is better for your health, that's why we are baking our own bread here, right ? :D
Yep Kollin, that's why I posted the link. We should all be interested in serving up the best real food possible.
Eric
I think a little wood pulp-derived cellulose is less alarming than a lot of the other ingredients found in that list of products. Maybe that's not saying much. Yikes! Makes me realize how spoiled (and lucky) I am to have a fresh loaf of bread and a garden full of veggies. Note to self: don’t ever take that for granted!
Marcus
Marcus. My wife bought some hamburger buns for a cookout and we didn't use them. They sat for about a month in a corner and looked as good as the day she bought them. If the mold and bacteria avoid 'em, perhaps we should too.
FF
What's the difference between wood fiber and plant stalks? or plant hulls?
The difference is in cellulose content. From wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellulose
Hmmm cotton... may be next time, when i'm mixing my dough I'll drop my t-shirt into the bowl :D
More interesting reading :
http://www.chem.cmu.edu/groups/collins/res/dyes.html
not so much that wood cellulose is being used as an ingredient as that there is no ceiling for the allowable quantity added to foods. That opens the door for all sorts of abuses by manufacturers. It is exactly the kind of thing that the FDA was created to prevent. Similar non-food additions to foods by unscrupulous producers led to the Reinheitsgebot in Germany to regulate the purity of beer and French laws that decree what is allowable in a baguette.
Cellulose, as a substance, is inescapable in foods containing fruits or vegetables. Although non-nutritive, cellulose is something that our bodies are equipped to deal with and is actually good for our health. In appropriate quantities. From appropriate sources. Without having been heavily processed, or altered from its original state.
I read the article while munching on a sandwich made with whole-wheat bread which contains a fair quantity of cellulose (wheat-sourced, not tree-sourced). Since I made it, I know what is in it. If something is presented as "food", then it should be real food, not ground-up tree. If someone wants to sell strawberry-flavored ground-up tree, more power to them. Just be honest and label it as such instead of calling it strawberry yogurt.
Paul
Just a little truth in advertising please.
Eric
One more reason why i bake bread at home.
Thanks, Eric