Submitted by chahira daoud on November 25, 2008 - 5:20pm

My bagels"first time"!!!!


Hello dear friends,

It is my first time to try bagels, the result was not bad, actually I can not judge because I have never taste it, I'll send you some to tell me how much did my recipe succeed.

Another question please , should bagels be a little bit chewy ,or I did knead too much my dough,,I am confused,anyway, it is not bad to try new recipes.

Thank you all and have a very nice day!!!

user icon

You did an excellent job!

Yes, they are supposed to be a bit chewy. They are often served here with cream cheese and lox (smoked salmon), red onion and tomato. We also have various flavored cream cheeses, sweet and savory. Did you like them?

Betty

user icon

Dear Betty, I have a cream

Dear Betty, I have a cream cheese ,I will go and try this, but I have first to send to Mr.Peter Reinhart a report about his bagels recipe.

Thank you for your nice words.

user icon

These look wonderful

Very nice bagels!

Sylvia

user icon

Thank you Sylvia, For your

Thank you Sylvia, For your wonderful words.

user icon

Very Beautiful!

Those look great! They should be a little chewy and those all look very good! I love the toppings!

Eli

user icon

Thank you Eli for your kind

Thank you Eli for your kind words, have a very nice day!!!

user icon

handsome bagels!

i've also just discovered the world of bagels, chahira, but yes, i think they're supposed to be chewy :-)

great photo! what recipe did you use for those bagels?

user icon

Dear Hans Thank you so much,

Dear Hans

Thank you so much, I am testing nowadays peter REinhart's new book's recipes,so I tried this recipe twice, first time , there was something wrong in dough , I think that was because I changed the kind of yeast,I am used to use.So this attempt,I used mine,and it worked as usual.

Chewy???

Yes, they are supposed to be chewy, but the question is, did you poach them first?  The true measure of a bagel is to boil them at first then bake them.  Boil for about 3 minutes per side, then put your seeds  on them, then into the oven.

 

I am no expert but I believe it is almost impossible to overknead bagel dough.  The stuff is remarkably stiff, and I generally knead my bagels for 15 minutes before resting then shaping.  By the way, I use Peters formulae in his book 'Crust To Crumb'.  In addition, you might find replacing the the honey with liquid barley malt appealing as well as using a soda/salt solution for boiling/poaching your dough before going into the oven.

 

Just some suggestions.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.