The Fresh Loaf

A Community of Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts.

In pursuit of perfection! ...... still a long way to go.

leslieruf's picture
leslieruf

In pursuit of perfection! ...... still a long way to go.

 

 

 

decided to make 3 batches of dough - and really pay attention to my gluten development and shaping.  Each batch was enough for 2 small loaves. I made Ru's butternut squash recipe again, my favourite multigrain and NW sourdoughs potato water SD.  I have made the multigrain recipe countless times but I reworked the recipe using the BBG spreadsheet. 

I started with the butternut squash.  As I had some squash frozen I defrosted it and used that.  It had a lot of moisture and I drained off what I could.  the dough was very very soft but seemed to come together ok with the 4 S&F at 30 minute intervals before bulk fermenting for a couple of hours.

once this was underway I started the multigrain. I added about an extra 20 g water to my soaker by accident and when I came to doing the autolyse my dough needed more water so I added water until it came together.  after autolyse I added the levain and soaker and it took a lot of hand mixing to combine.  The S&f were then matched to the butternut dough so I did one dough followed by the next.  the dough was very soft.

ok, onto the last one.  potato water SD.  this recipe uses the double hydration technique. I mixed the low hydration dough, added the levain then left to rest for 2 hours with s&f after 1 hour. final step is to added 2nd part of water with the salt gradually over 3-4 hours with gentle s&f.

Finally, as each dough finished bulk ferment I preshaped, rested and shaped dough.  It was quite a challenge with the butternut squash dough. It was really soft and very extensible and I struggled to get it to hold its shape. the multigrain gave me similar shaping problems but I hoped i had done enough. finally the potato water dough was just a beeze, no issues at all.

so into the fridge they went for overnight proof. set the oven to heatup automatically and started my baking.

here is the butternut squash.

Really spread during bake and I was very disappointed. next to be baked the multigrain.

 

Spread quite a bit too, but was a bit better. I hade made a slightly bigger batch so the 2 loaves were 800 and 600 gms

finally the potato water dough went into the oven.  i made 1 boule (photo at top of post) and the batard I baked in a oblong china dish with tented foil over it. normally i bake in DO but wanted to try this.  I slashed the top. I had used parchment during proofing so I could allow dish to warm up befoe putting in the oven. anyway, put loaf in oven and after 15 minutes removed lid of DO and foil from dish. it was way less baked than the boule so l left it another 5 minutes then removed it from the dish so it would brown.

this also needed longer to finish.  all loaves baked to 208°f internal temp.yy

later in the day, i sliced and packaged.  the grain and butternut loaves are very moist, never had that before.

 

the crumb shot cheered me up a bit, but I was disappointed given the extra care i had taken to try and do things better.

proof will be in the eating over Christmas.

Leslie

Comments

dabrownman's picture
dabrownman

Perfect for Christmas!  Well done and happy baking!

joc1954's picture
joc1954

The butternut squash could be very hard, I had the same problems when I was baking a miche of about 3kg for the altar at Thanksgiving Sunday. The loaf came out of my WFO quite flat, but was delicious to eat. Whenever you want to get really a great looking bread at least one thing goes wrong or maybe even more. You have recovered from your problems in a very good way!

Happy baking and Merry Christmas Leslie!

Joze

leslieruf's picture
leslieruf

yep, butternut squash loaf does taste good. I was quite staggered at how much residue the cooked loaves left on my knife, but they don't taste gummy.  I am trying to get a better shape (dabrownman your loaves always look so good with great oven spring where mine seem to be quite a lot flatter) I think I need to reduce hydration a little too and I also get the feeling the flour is a little different to usual lately, not so thirsty.  

Anyway, thanks for the encouragement.  Happy baking

Leslie

Ru007's picture
Ru007

I'm glad youre enjoying the butternut squash loaf :)

The crumb looks incredible on all three of the loaves, beautifully open. 

I think i'm on the same "pursuit of perfection" journey as you, I've been making the same loaf over and over again until i get good results consistently. 

I think you have the right idea with lowering the hydration to get better spring, i've been working with lower hydration and the loaves are holding their shape better. For me the tricky part, is trying to handle my dough better to still get a nice open crumb without relying on really hydration dough :) Its been fun experimenting. 

Anyway, great post, i'm sure the loaves will all be delicious for Christmas. 

Happy baking 

Ru

leslieruf's picture
leslieruf

not only in the the bread department  and have thoroughly enjoyed it.  New recipes for meringues (mixed spice & cranberry), florentines, lemon shortbread based on drogon's (I think) shortbread recipe, fruit gummies, salted caramel chocolate truffles to mention a few. LOL, bit much sweet stuff, but it is only Christmas once a year!  

so back to bread, thank you Ru and happy baking

Leslie

PalwithnoovenP's picture
PalwithnoovenP

Some lacked spring but the insides were incredible. Sometimes when you do many things at once, many could go wrong also. Maybe you can focus on one and do another next time but I know you are talented so next time will be definitely better!

leslieruf's picture
leslieruf

the process went quite smoothly as I completed each bread on its own. The S & F ended up happening in succession but the end of bulk ferments & final shaping was staggered so while there was a lot happening it wasn't too bad and I enjoyed the day.  In the past I have ended up being quite fazed and had decided to bake only one batch of bread on a bake day. Lol!  looking forward to better baking in 2017

Leslie

PalwithnoovenP's picture
PalwithnoovenP
Isand66's picture
Isand66

Your crumb shots look great.  Just wondering if you took the water content of the butternut squash into account?  It is about 86% water so that is probably why your dough was so slack and difficult to shape.  I keep a little sticky note with different ingredient hydration's above my computer so I can revise my formulas so they are not too hydrated.

Regards,
Ian

leslieruf's picture
leslieruf

the squash was very wet and although I did try and drain liquid off, I obviously didn't take this into account enough. I think next time I must remember to hold some water back until the squash is incorporated! It is an on going learning curve for sure.

It is a good idea to keep a note of the hydration of ingredients as you do. I aim to use bakers percent and my spreadsheet more often. This bake used recipes reworked using my newly setup spreadsheet based on BBGA's one from the link that alfanso posted a little while ago so I may have to tweak it a little. 

thanks Ian and happy baking

Leslie