The Fresh Loaf

News & Information for Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts

Detmolder Sourdough With And Without Yeast - Comparison

Juergen Krauss's picture
Juergen Krauss

Detmolder Sourdough With And Without Yeast - Comparison

For some time I have been looking for German bread formulas, although not systematically. Some time ago I came across Meister Süpke's Blog about sourdough, and setting up a German group at my Son's school gave me finally the incentive to try out Mr Süpke's formulas for bread using the "Detmolder Einstufen-Führung" as I agreed to provide the bread.

Bread according to these formulas (see German Baking Day) can be made with various amounts of wheat and rye using a stiff rye starter at 80% hydration that has been refreshed with 5%-10% mature starter and kept at 24C to 28C for 12 to 18 hours. The Detmolder single step process uses a small amount of commercial yeast in the final dough.

The yeast content raised some questions: Is it necessary? Is the bread loosing sourdough characteristics? Are the bakers in Germany giving up quality in favor of quantity?

From Meister Süpke I got the answer that he could make the bread without yeast added, but in order to get through his schedule he has one hour for the final proof, which is being archieved by adding 1% yeast or less.

Another answer comes from Daniel DiMuzio's book Breadmaking: For some formulas he says one can add up to 0.7% of instant yeast without changing the character of the bread significantly, e.g. p.232, San Francisco Style Sourdough

Well, I wanted to know if the yeast does more than cutting the prooving times short, so I did some comparative baking.

First some pictures.

The 60% Rye loaves:

 

The 30% and 100% rye loaves:

 

Conclusion:

Quite surprisingly, there is hardly any noticeable difference in the appearance the bakes with and without yeast. The slightly higher volume of the loaves with altus are due to the additional amount of altus in the dough, I didn't scale those down to 500g.

The loaves with altus were also a bit chewier and tasted more earthy. There was a slight difference between the 60% rye with and without yeast, the sourdough only version being milder. And the 100% rye with yeast maintained a bit of the starter's fruity notes.

The only striking difference loies in the times for the final proof, as shown in the table with the formulas below.

This experiment would suggest that the yeast is not necessary, but it is a great tool to fit this type of bread into a production schedule without the loss of quality. I would be very interested to hear if anyone has different experiences.

Now to some details about the process:

Starters:

All the breads in this comparison call for a rye starter with 80% hydration. For the 60% rye batch I used wholegrain rye flour, for the others I used light rye flour (Type 997). I am maintaining a liquid wholegrain rye "mother" at 200% hydration, which is very reliable and worked well as a seed culture.

The starters were made in two elaborations (same process for wholegrain and light rye starters):

 1. 100% flour, 80% water, 10% mother fermented at 24C for 16 hours

2. 100% flour, 80% water, 10% starter from (1) fermented at 24C for 16 hours

This way the original liquid "mother" makes up just 1% of the starter - no worries about the wrong hydration or grain. The starters rose well to about four times their original volume, and had a nice tangy smell. The light rye starter developed a very nice fruity-flowery smell.

The altus (fresh "old bread", 80% rye) has been added to the water for the 2nd elaboration to soak. No aditional water added. There was very little difference in the starter consistency with and without altus.

Ingredient100% Rye100% Rye + Yeast60% Rye60% Rye + Yeast60% Rye + Altus60% Rye + Yeast + Altus30% Rye30% Rye + Yeast
Straight Formula, in baker's percent
Wholegrain Rye  60606060  
Light Rye100100    3030
Wholegrain Wheat  8888  
White Wheat  323232327070
Water7878747474747171
Salt22222222
Instant Yeast 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3
Altus    1010  
Yield180180.3176176.3186186.3173173.3
Wholegrain Rye from starter  25252525  
Light Rye from starter3535    1818
Final Dough, in grams
Wholegrain Rye  186186186186  
Light Rye187187    3636
Wholegrain Wheat  25252525  
White Wheat  99999999209209
Water144144167167167167169169
Salt5.75.76.26.26.26.266
Instant Yeast 1 1 1 1
Altus    1010  
Starter1811811411411411419797
Timing in minutes,
Ambient Temperature28C28C27C27C27C27C24C28C
Bulk Rise4040404040404030
Final Proof65501037484569060

Comments

RonRay's picture
RonRay

Juergen, I very much like the detail in your posting. I wish more people would provide such worthwhile observations, as well.

Thanks, again-

Ron

Juergen Krauss's picture
Juergen Krauss

Ron, Your kind comment is highly appreciated.

I am an admirer of the graphical quality of your posts!

Juergen

Mini Oven's picture
Mini Oven

both with and without yeast in the 60% rye loaves.  :)

Juergen Krauss's picture
Juergen Krauss

Mini, That is true.

Obviously, the yeasts get a bit more predigested food this way.

 

AnnaInMD's picture
AnnaInMD

did you bake the above with or without steam, actually, how did you bake them - gas, electric, convection and in what containers ?  I cannot see the third picture, you might have addressed some of my questions.

Thanks much, great job !

Anna

Juergen Krauss's picture
Juergen Krauss

Thank you, Anna.

There should be four pictures - but they probably wouldn't answer all your questions; pictures 2 and 4 are shots of the 100% and 30% ryes.

My oven is a simple fan oven, and Mini and others helped me to get the most out of it.

I baked with steam at about 230C, turning down to 200 after 10 minutes for another 20 minutes.Total about 30 minutes.

All loaves are 500g. I baked the 100% and 60% ones in tins, brushed with water before and after the bake.

The 35% ryes have been prooved in baskets.

Let me know if the pictures turn up, if not I can make them available in a different way.

Thanks again,

Juergen

AnnaInMD's picture
AnnaInMD

popped up,  wonderful bakes, Jürgen !

Thank you !

anna

 

Janetcook's picture
Janetcook

Juergen,

Thanks so much for not only experimenting with SD and yeast added versions of these breads but for documenting it so clearly and presenting it here for others to learn about your results.

We were discussing this on your last blog and I am so happy you followed up the discussion of why commercial yeast is added to loaves in German recipes.  Not only did you hypothesize why it was added but you have now provided proof!  

I think of the Professor Clavel (sp) and all he added to restoring bread to it's former standards and I can't help but think that people here - you very much included - are still following suit by searching out your own answers and baking in your own kitchen to come up with 'traditional' breads.  

It is a cycle to be sure.  The old way worked and then something changed it -$$$$ and time constraints - a good motivator I might add ;-).   People switched to the 'new'  (people wanting to be modern!) and soon the old ways were forgotten.  How easily the simple things are forgotten and the basic premises lost....

I imagine that German bakers, like the French bakers, gravitated to commercial yeast for very obvious reasons and then a switch occurred which resulted in bringing SD back but with the addition of commercial yeast in their formulas and that is how it has remained until now when people like you are not only questioning the methods but are running your own baking experiments as well!  An example of living history - not sure we can live history though because it is always the present but that is an entirely different topic *^).

I feel very fortunate to be able to use your hard work in baking breads in my own kitchen without having to run the experiments you have done.  Not only do I get the results of your experiments but I get some lovely formulas too.

Thanks so much!

Take Care,

Janet

 

Juergen Krauss's picture
Juergen Krauss

Janet,

It's a joy and often a surprise to untangle the threads of regional taste, commerial interest and natural ressource aavailability.

I am learning a lot in the process, and I am glad it is useful to you, too.

Juergen

ananda's picture
ananda

These are all very fine breads, Juergen, and the post makes an excellent read.

Thank you for writing up this experiment.

In commercial bakeries, where the sour is in constant use, and where you apply rigorous feeding schedule as you describe, in your homebaking, then the sour will perform in a way which renders the additional use of yeast as unecessary.   In these circumstances, the yeast is there exactly for the reason you discovered...to speed up final proof.

But, if the sour being used has been less well tended, or has been allowed to ferment a bit long, then the yeast will act as a form of insurance policy to some extent at least.

I really like the whole range of breads you have produced here.

Best wishes

Andy

Juergen Krauss's picture
Juergen Krauss

Thank you for your comments, Andy.

and for the clarification of the difference between homebaking and professional environments.

By the way, I'm going to get some flour from Plumpton Mill, Then I'll have a go with your miche.

Thanks,

Juergen