butter v. oil
Does vegetable oil work as a substitute for butter in baking yeast breads? I use it (or applesauce) in baking other stuff. I don't have access to butter or shortening.
Does vegetable oil work as a substitute for butter in baking yeast breads? I use it (or applesauce) in baking other stuff. I don't have access to butter or shortening.
I made two simple loaves (flour, salt, yeast, both W/ 8% suger), but I experiemented with vegetable oil versus butter. One loaf with 8% oil, and the other with 8% unsalted Butter. 2 hour rise, then shape, then 1 hour proof. Oven at 450, baked till centers were 200 degrees.
1st one had VERY distinctive vegetable oil taste and smell compared to the one with butter. Side by side, you would taste both, and want to through the one with Vegetable oil away to the birds.
Hi,
Thanks for your help on this topic. I searched all over the web, and nobody even on this impressive site had the recipe I was looking for. Fortunately, a family member found an old copy of this spectacular, no-knead, crusty bread. Always a hit w. my people on special occasions. Anyone who would like to substitute more specific measurements (like 'stick of butter'), please do!
Monkey Bread (so-called by the friend of my mother who gave her the recipe circa '68)
Hi,
This is my first post, and hope you can help. My mother's buttery egg bread recipe has disappeared, and I need it for next week. It consists of flour, eggs, milk, yeast, and salt. Makes a batter like dough, which rises in the fridge, with one punch down, then left overnight. It's dropped, soft and spongy, into loaf pans coated with melted butter, resulting in a crunchy crust. So, I know the outline, just need to recoup the details and proportions.
Sound familiar? The troops are hungry!
This post is a bit off topic as it's really about nutritional quality of the ingredients rather than baking quality.
A recent post on trans fats got me thinking about good ole lard. I've never cooked or baked with it, but I understand it is available for purchase in many places now. My addled brain says that it is in fact less of a health problem than the hydrogenated vegetable shortening which replaced it.
I cook and bake with butter - OK, sometimes way too much butter. From a nutrition standpoint is lard really any different?
While I'm not ready to take up butter-making just yet, I enjoyed reading about the process. Great pictures, too.