The Fresh Loaf

News & Information for Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts

Sourdough International culture reviews?

  • Pin It
nmr82's picture
nmr82

Sourdough International culture reviews?

Has anyone tried/had good experiences with Sourdough International or their France culture? 

 

Thanks!

Faith in Virginia's picture
Faith in Virginia

Think I gave you the link on the other post.

They were great people to deal with.  I got a few starters from them and they all sucessfully activated.  I think I got the Italian and it came with two starters. Both got activated but I could not tell them apart.  Could have been me, my nose or my taste.  I had others taste the bread for differences and nobody could tell the difference from one to the other.  So I let one go and have been maintaining  the one ever since.

Doc.Dough's picture
Doc.Dough

I have purchased three starters from SDI and all of them started. However, the literature that he sends with the starters is so misleading as to create more problems (misconceptions) than the normal beginner can deal with.  Just throw out the literature and use the advice found elsewhere on this site. 

One of the starters I bought was the French variety to make a mild flavored loaf. But after I learned more about starters in general I found that I could make a mild sourdough anytime I wanted with any starter I had. So I threw out the "French" starter.  

Faith in Virginia's picture
Faith in Virginia

If you lived near me I would give you some starter...ready to go.  Perhaps some TFLer lives close to you and would be willing to share their starter.

I'm a starter doner in my area. 

Azazello's picture
Azazello

If you got it working and kept it going, after a while, you'd end up with a starter particular to your area, wouldn't you? It wouldn't be French for long.

I'd save the cash and follow one of the many excellent guides around on starting and maintaining your own.

 

Doc.Dough's picture
Doc.Dough

Buy a known good starter so that you have something that you have confidence in. After you get used to it you can start one of your own and you will be prepared to know whether it is good or not. This is one reason why I recommend against the Sourdough International starters. They are not known good starters. Get some live starter from a friend or buy starter from King Arthur.

Sjadad's picture
Sjadad

I didn't know anyone in my area with a starter when I began bread baking five years ago.  I bought some from King Arthur Flour and have kept it alive ever since.  I typically bake once a week or so and feed it on the same schedule (whether I bake or not).  I have neglected it for as long as a month, but after a few refresher feedings it has always come roaring back, robust and ready to go.

I agree with Azazello - after a few feedings in your kitchen it will be your own microclimate starter; this is why Hamelman calls his formula Vermont Sourdough and not San Francisco Sourdough.  His starter is polulated by the wild yeasts and bacteria local to Norwich, Vermont.

Thaichef's picture
Thaichef

Good Morning all:

I borrow a "Classic Sourdoughs  book"from the library yesterday and ponder about buying the sourdough starter from them. The  gentleman writer, Dr. Ed Wood MD,PhD is a physician and research scientist with a lot of serious quest. He has more than 10 starters from all over the world to sell and it costs from $10 to $14 each.

  I questioned the recipes(in the book)since most of the recipe used as much as "one cup to two cups of sourdough culture" in it. I have about 3 oz. of sourdough in my jar. He recommended using 1 quart(1 liter)glass jar for storage and make large amount of sourdough. In fact, non of his recipe using less than one cup.

I was going to write to the TFL members to see if anyone using his recipe yet?  I stored a small amount of sourdough in my 8 oz. size mason jar only and feed it once a week.

And Faith, we live close so any sourdough starter  you want to give to me is very much appreciated. ( I only have one major one, regular wheat flour). 

Comments? 

mantana

Faith in Virginia's picture
Faith in Virginia

Dr. Ed Wood started the sourdough international.  That is where I got my first culture from.

Doc.Dough is totally correct about the literature that comes with his cultures.  More then confusing.

I have that book but can't say I remember baking from it.  I will look at it tonight.  I tend to work from books that have measures in weights and use bakers %. 

You are more then welcome to any of my starters.  I keep a white ,rye, and WW.   I am currently testing a method for starting a starter found in this thread.

http://www.thefreshloaf.com/node/31770/light-end-tunnel-would-be-really-useful-right-now

I decided to try two using this method one white one WW.  Once active I will compare them to my older starters and make some baked bread comparisons.

They are calling for snow any time now so I hope you'r stocked up and have some baking ideas if you get snowed in.  It's Dad's birthday today so I am baking him a Coco Angle Cake and will do a chocolate butter cream icing.   Sugar on top of sugar  just the way Dad likes it.

But we can get together when the roads clear.

Faith

Thaichef's picture
Thaichef

Good Afternoon on the wet, cold and drizzly day:

  Thank you for your offer and when the weather is better perhaps, we can meet for lunch in say..Roanoke or Salem. Let me buy your lunch for your trouble from the long  drive from your place. O.K.?

mantana

 

 

nmr82's picture
nmr82

Thanks all!

 

I've got a couple different starters going, they seem to be growing, look okay, I'm not sure what I'm looking for in terms of smell lol

 

I want to make the Vermont Sourdough (I'm from Vermont), I'm a little confused about what is considered "mature" .

 

 

thanks!

Faith in Virginia's picture
Faith in Virginia

Sounds great! I have your info and you have mine so we  can work that out.   Snowing like a bad dog now.

nm82  that sounds great... there is no reason you can't start your own.  I'll be in VT at the end of February(taking a class at King Arthur and visiting all my family that lives up there.  Vermont Sourdough is one of my favorites and I bake it all the time.

"mature" just is a starter that has stabilized and becomes predictable .  I'll be testing a young starter this weekend...just 5 days from starting.  We will see how that turns out.

Faith

 

ars pistorica's picture
ars pistorica

Save your money, get some flour and water, and make your own.  Dried cultures are best bought from bigger companies that specialise in isolating and preparing the cultures for the industrial-sector, and are only of real use in semi-sterile conditions, which no home-baker on this site is operating in.